Get Our Newsletter!

School system foresees little impact from condos
Email Print

Parker: Enrollment fraud aggresively investigated
By SUSAN LEATHERS

Brentwood Home Page
During discussions of the Bristol at Centerview, the 393-unit mixed-use residential development now approved in the city’s Town Center district, opponents often brought up the impact it would have on Williamson County Schools’ Brentwood campuses, specifically Lipscomb Elementary, Brentwood Middle and Brentwood High Schools.

Two primary arguments against the rezoning and subsequent site plan approval that concerned schools included residential fraud – people renting the units to have a Brentwood address while actually living outside of the local school zones, and school population growth – worries that with the development’s high density, families would crowd into the one- and two-bedroom units in order to attend Brentwood-area public schools.

“We really think it’s not going to have a huge impact,” said Susan Parker, WCS’ planning and zoning specialist. “The positive thing is that we were made aware of it very early in the process.”

From an enrollment perspective, Lipscomb, Brentwood Middle and Brentwood High all have room for additional students, Parker said. She compared projected enrollments for the new school year against each school’s actual capacity.

She could not use comparative data from similar developments like the Bristol on Broadway in Nashville or Dwell in Cool Springs because both of those feed into different school systems (Metro and Franklin Special School District). Gateway Village, located just over Brentwood’s southern Brentwood city limits, is zoned for Brentwood schools but includes townhomes, flats, and single-family homes as well as residential over retail. Parker estimated that the total number of students in grades K-12 living at Gateway Village is no more than 100.

The Bristol at Centerview has an estimated build-out time of one to two years, Parker noted. “Honestly, it will take some units being developed before we can get some real history to work with.” However, all of the information shared by the city has led Parker to believe the impact will be limited.

“They eliminated the three-bedroom concept because they were worried about the schools,” she said. That, coupled with the development’s target markets – young professionals, single professionals, downsizers and retirees who have second homes, a Brentwood ordinance that does not allow month-to-month leases and projected rents of $900 to $2100 a month all helped shape Parker’s view that the number of children that ultimately reside at Bristol will not have a huge impact.

When it comes to parents trying to defraud the school system on residency, WCS is aggressive in both its investigation of claims or tips and in taking action once fraud is determined.

“We have people who commit fraud all over the county,” not just Brentwood, said WCS spokesperson Carol Birdsong. The system has a “Fraud Line” – 472-5555 – and encourages anyone who suspects a child may be illegally enrolled in a school to phone in the details.

“We ask that you give as much information as possible,” Birdsong said. “We will investigate. We will hire a private investigator if needed.”

If fraud is determined, the system bills the family for the cost of tuition and the child or children are asked to be withdrawn immediately.

In the 2010-11 school year, Parker said at least 12 to 15 families were investigated who lived in counties outside of Williamson. That number rises significantly when it includes investigations within the district, of children attending schools outside of their assigned zone using another person’s address.

“We investigate those the same way,” Parker said.

Most fraud cases come to the central office from other parents, “who are Williamson County tax payers,” Parker said.

Last year, as it does every few years, WCS required every student for proof of residency. This year, every student who is attending a new school – even those who are feeding into the next level within their feeder pattern – must prove residency.

Current residents much show two current utility bills (e.g. gas, water, electric) that indicate current address. New students whose families have not yet set up utilities must show a lease agreement or contract on a new home. Contracts contingent on the sale of a family’s existing home are not accepted, Parker noted.

Families who are awaiting the completion of a new home or expect to move into a new home within the district during a current semester can pay $2487.50 in order to go ahead and enroll a child. “We want to see the contract,” Parker said. “If you move in within the same semester you’ll be reimbursed in full.” If you don’t, the money is not returned.

Enrollment information for Williamson County Schools can be found by clicking here.

 

Printer-friendly format


Member Opinions:
By: MidTn37027 on 8/8/11
Great article. Always good to see facts amidst the misinformation out there.

By: jayv1234 on 8/8/11
“We really think it’s not going to have a huge impact,” FYI - when you "think" something its not fact, its an opinion. Does not make it wrong, but no one will really know until these units are occupied.

By: GrantHammond on 8/8/11
Why are you calling these condos in the title of your story? These are luxury apartments.

By: KublaKhan on 8/8/11
[By: jayv1234 on 8/8/11
“We really think it’s not going to have a huge impact,” FYI - when you "think" something its not fact, its an opinion. Does not make it wrong, but no one will really know until these units are occupied. ]

Seriously? When the administrators say "think," they mean educated guess based on facts at hand. Did you read the article? No 3-bedroom units, and the lowest rent will be $900/mo. There is no way that the dreaded poor people (oh no!) are going to be able to pony up in droves to "take advantage" of Brentwood schools, and if they do, they'd be pretty motivated, and would probably make great neighbors.

Besides, (quoted from the article): "From an enrollment perspective, Lipscomb, Brentwood Middle and Brentwood High all have room for additional students, Parker said. She compared projected enrollments for the new school year against each school’s actual capacity." - So even if some families do move in, the schools have space to absorb them.

By: turk182 on 8/9/11
They are called condos in teh title because that's what they are, plotted and deeded.

By: MidTn37027 on 8/9/11
Geez. What part of "deeded as condominiums...taxed seperately" do people not want to get? That's what they are. Legally. End of story.

As they say, that's a fact, not an opinion. Whatever they end up 10 years for now is the opinion part.

By: localboy on 8/9/11
"Most fraud cases come to the central office from other parents, “who are Williamson County tax payers,” Parker said."
Well, well so you aren't paranoid - your neighbors ARE watching you...;)

By: localboy on 8/9/11
"That number rises significantly when it includes investigations within the district, of children attending schools outside of their assigned zone using another person’s address."..."Most fraud cases come to the central office from other parents, “who are Williamson County tax payers,” Parker said."
Alert-those in-district cases involve parents who are county tax payers, too.

By: jac2071 on 8/9/11
To Turk and MidTn, I am in real estate, so I am not ignorant to the issue of what these units are called. Your "end of story" comment is a bit arrogant and ignorant. The issue is not that black and white. These are rental units, truly apartments.

Let's be honest, a tenant who signs a lease is never concerned with how things are "deeded" and handled behind the scenes. To them, it is a rental/apartment. they have no ownership stake, and will thus treat their time there as such. Just like any other apartment they can rent in town. To them, it does not matter.

So don't drink the grape juice and die on the sword of "deeded as condos". Ownership is irrelevant. Renters will be living there for the foreseeable future. Walks like a duck...

By: jmf-rock on 8/9/11
if you read the C-4 zoning code - the term condominium is the term necessary to comply with the ordinance and a unit owners association is also necessary - generally i think most people that are familiar with "owning" a condo find a "homeowners association" to be essential to maintenance of their investment - the key term is homeowner - the thing i think most folks are concerned about is the fact that 192 of these units are so small they don't seem like the type condominium which will ever lend itself to be sold and any type of unit association that the developer chooses is what we as well as those who rent or lease will be stuck with.- when this town center concept was originally planned it was not intended to be of this nature in size and scope. one of our planning commissioners ask if a school bus would be able to navigate the turn into these units - if this turns out to be the jump start some commissioners hope for and more similar "condo" situations in the C-4 area follow what will the impact on traffic and schools be? i don't think anyone has told us what the population density for this C-4 area can potentially be - already 393 units, whatever you call them, is like at least a 200 home subdivision. i just don't think expanding the scope of a good idea is at all what most of us envisioned with the town center..


Login and voice your opinion!
Do you know someone else who would like to see this?
Your Email:
Their Email:
Comment:
(Will be included with e-mail)
Secret Code

In the box below, enter the Secret Code exactly as it appears above *